CARNELIAN

[dramatispersonae]

[Unlike with previous games from Lancelot, the room today is sparse … and cold, as if this is a place where some of the remaining winter hasn’t left (though surely that has nothing to do with the Snow Queen …)

Instead of wine, bread, and meat, there is dirty water, some berries (that are safe to eat), and some other plants that clearly have been picked off a plant.

There is nowhere to really sit except the cold, hard ground.]

Comments

ROUND ONE

[dramatispersonae]

In the past, I betrayed my oath to my king. I was not truly loyal to him, not as I was meant to be. Did you know … we were friends when we were young, though perhaps not as young as many of you? We came to be brothers. And still, I hurt him. I broke that vow.

So I must ask you, Aather. What are the sins … or crimes … of your team? Please list three.

DISCUSSION

[dramatispersonae]

Re: DISCUSSION

[rubicsbrat]

Who the hell cares?

[ just sort of looking at the rest of the team ]

You got anything to share?

Re: DISCUSSION

[scarygirl]

Does it count if you believe you were in the right?

[This is an important distinction, she's got some shit here that might qualify.]

Re: DISCUSSION

[itsjustafayz]

How about revenge?

SUBMIT

[dramatispersonae]

Please list only three. No more, no less.

Re: SUBMIT

[itsjustafayz]

1. Indifference toward morality.
2. A focus on revenge.
3. Selfishness.

ROUND TWO

[dramatispersonae]

When Arthur learned of my betrayal, of what I had done—he did nothing. A strong king in every way, but in the face of betrayal from a loved one, he could only stand by and do nothing. His mercy led his realm to despair; many others thought him to be weak.

They weren’t right. But they were correct in another way: I was deserving of punishment. A crime is not a crime without the punishment that follows, some might say, but some crimes are worthy of punishment.

Today, list three suggested punishments for any crimes, worthy crimes, perhaps even your own crimes.

DISCUSSION

[dramatispersonae]

Re: DISCUSSION

[rubicsbrat]

This is getting dumber.

Re: DISCUSSION

[withreverence]

He deserves nothing less than death for betraying his lord. It's not worthy of discussion.

Re: DISCUSSION

[scarygirl]

Treachery should be repaid with treachery. I stand by that.

Re: DISCUSSION

[itsjustafayz]

Put them in the stocks for a while. You know, like in the olden days.

SUBMIT

[dramatispersonae]

Three punishments here. No more, no less. They can be anything.

ROUND THREE

[dramatispersonae]

Surely you have all witnessed the importance of being held accountable. Would Camelot have been so cold, so burdened, had Arthur punished me correctly? Would the Snow Queen have experienced such misery?

Now, hold your other Aatherites accountable in the same way. So many crimes have surely come to pass that it is time for them to face it.

Tell me one team you find guilty, and the reason for that guilt.

And … tell me one team you find to be innocent. This is according to your own understanding, of course.

DISCUSSION

[dramatispersonae]

SUBMIT

[dramatispersonae]

One innocent team, one guilty team and the reason for that guilt.

ROUND FOUR

[dramatispersonae]

Today, you have been accused twice, for being not guilty, and of being neither guilty nor innocent. However, you were protected from these crimes, and you do not have to do penance.

The choices for penances are here.

I have been found guilty for not listening to reason, and I will do the penances suggested by Jasper:

1. For the crime of running tiresome and intrusive games, to only run cheerful and pleasant games from now on.
2. For the crime of being obsessed with his own self-judgment, to tell the story of his supposed crime, and to hear and accept someone else's judgment of him.
3. For the crime of betraying his friend, to apologize sincerely and actually accept the judgment of his friend in this instance, since it seems to be harder for him than any self-flagellating punishment we could give him. And to apply the energies he's no longer using to mentally punish himself to something productive, to find his king and remedy the damage he's done.

Re: ROUND FOUR

[scarygirl]

...unexpected.

Re: ROUND FOUR

[itsjustafayz]

Huh.

Re: ROUND FOUR

[withreverence]

If his friend is his king, it's acceptable to face his judgment. It's the lord who's at fault for not punishing treachery as it deserves.

BONUS

[dramatispersonae]

What are ways you have dealt with the guilt in your past, in your memories? What if you betrayed a friend and destroyed something very important? How would you recommend making up for it, if not through the means here in this game?

Also, would you like your crimes to be public knowledge?

Re: BONUS

[scarygirl]

You can't "deal with" what you don't feel. But I would aid in un-destroying what had been ruined, I suppose. I have.

And I cannot imagine they are not public knowledge already.

Re: BONUS

[withreverence]

I don't remember enough of my past to know if there was guilt. My memories are of acting rightfully in service of my lord. But if I had ever betrayed anyone I would want it to be known and to face my punishment!

Re: BONUS

[itsjustafayz]

Just try to make things better, if you can. Sometimes you can't, and you just have to live with that.

Sure.